When is it appropriate to use rigid support systems instead of flexible ones?

Using rigid support systems is most appropriate when severely damaged or stressed limbs need stabilization. In such cases, rigid supports provide the necessary strength and stability to prevent further injury or failure of the limb. This is crucial for maintaining the structural integrity of the tree and promoting recovery. Rigid systems can effectively withstand high loads and resist movement, which is essential when dealing with compromised tree parts that could pose risks to both the tree and its surroundings.

In contrast, flexible supports are better suited for healthy limbs, as they allow for some movement and can accommodate natural growth and sway. When aesthetic appeal is a priority, the selection of support systems may lean towards less intrusive options—or those that blend more naturally with the tree's appearance—rather than rigid supports. Finally, for trees that have not yet grown significantly, the need for either type of support system may be minimal, as young trees often have not developed the structural challenges that necessitate support.